PAC - Planning Appeals Commission Appeal Decisions

Appeal Decisions

PAC Reference Appellant(s) Decision Decision Date Planning Service Reference Planning Office Article
Macrete Ireland Limited Allowed 17/05/2019 TC 34/88 Northern Ireland Environment Agency
Mr Stephen White Allowed 15/05/2019 LA01/2018/0812/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Adrian Carvill Allowed 13/05/2019 LA07/2017/1497/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
EDB Construction Limited Dismissed 13/05/2019 LA07/2018/1074/F Newry, Mourne and Down 60
Mr David Thompson Dismissed 13/05/2019 LA04/2018/2440/F Belfast 58
Mrs Tracey Blair EnforcementNoticeUpheld 13/05/2019 LA01/2015/0140/LA Causeway Coast and Glens 44
A & E Mulholland EnforcementNoticeUpheld 10/05/2019 EN/2015/0109 Department of the Environment
Mr Frank McNeill Dismissed 10/05/2019 LA03/2018/0063/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr Peter Clerkin Allowed 08/05/2019 LA07/2017/0969/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Niall Black Dismissed 08/05/2019 P/2015/0200/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Lagan Group EnforcementNoticeUpheld 07/05/2019 EN/2015/0109 Department of the Environment
Northstone (NI) Limited EnforcementNoticeUpheld 07/05/2019 EN/2015/0109 Department of the Environment
Norman Emerson Group Limited EnforcementNoticeUpheld 07/05/2019 EN/2015/0109 Department of the Environment
P & J Walls EnforcementNoticeUpheld 07/05/2019 EN/2015/0109 Department of the Environment
Shaftesbury Estate of Lough Neagh EnforcementNoticeUpheld 07/05/2019 EN/2015/0109 Department of the Environment
Michael Simpson Dismissed 03/05/2019 LA02/2018/0892/O Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr Geoff Angus NotValid 02/05/2019 LA05/2018/0420/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 60
Ms Pamela Wilson Withdrawn 01/05/2019 LA04/2018/0860/F Belfast 58
Patrick McManus Dismissed 29/04/2019 LA04/2018/0535/F Belfast 58
Lotus Homes (UK) Ltd Allowed 29/04/2019 LA03/2018/0284/A Antrim and Newtownabbey 15
Mr David Hewitt Dismissed 29/04/2019 LA10/2018/0858/O Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Mr NEIL SCORESBY Allowed 29/04/2019 LA04/2018/0930/F Belfast 58
Mr NEIL SCORESBY Allowed 29/04/2019 LA04/2018/0944/A Belfast 15
O'Hagan Construction Dismissed 29/04/2019 LA07/2017/1316/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Leah Chambers Dismissed 29/04/2019 LA07/2018/0921/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Dundarave Properties Withdrawn 25/04/2019 EN/2018/0269 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Dundarve Properties Withdrawn 25/04/2019 LA01/2018/1571/LDE Causeway Coast and Glens
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 24/04/2019 LA04/2018/0868/F Belfast 58
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 24/04/2019 LA04/2018/0645/A Belfast 15
Mr Andrew Keys Allowed 19/04/2019 LA10/2018/1052/F Fermanagh and Omagh 60
Mr Andrew Keys EnforcementNoticeQuashed 19/04/2019 LA10/2017/0142/CA Fermanagh and Omagh 143
Mr Andrew Keys Allowed 19/04/2019 LA10/2018/1022/F Fermanagh and Omagh 60
Ms Claire Kidd Withdrawn 19/04/2019 LA04/2018/1440/F Belfast
Mr Andrew Keys Allowed 19/04/2019 LA10/2018/1042/F Fermanagh and Omagh 60
Mr Andrew Keys Allowed 19/04/2019 LA10/2018/1053/F Fermanagh and Omagh 60
McGrisken Properties Allowed 18/04/2019 LA11/2017/1111/F Derry and Strabane 58
Ms Kerri McFadden Dismissed 17/04/2019 LA10/2018/0617/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Amulet Developments NI Ltd Allowed 17/04/2019 LA03/2018/0529/A Antrim and Newtownabbey 15
Clark McCourt Dismissed 17/04/2019 LA07/2017/1151/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Daniel O'Loan Dismissed 16/04/2019 LA02/2018/0527/O Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr Thomas Stevenson Dismissed 15/04/2019 LA07/2017/1624/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Ms Emma Hogg Allowed 15/04/2019 LA04/2018/1599/A Belfast 15
Mr Andrew Carleton Dismissed 12/04/2019 LA08/2017/1715/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mr Paul McAliskey EnforcementNoticeUpheld 10/04/2019 LA09/2018/0001/CA Mid Ulster
Mr Stephen Magowan Dismissed 09/04/2019 LA02/2018/0061/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr Patrick McAuley Allowed 09/04/2019 LA02/2017/0950/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Miss Andrea Sinclair Dismissed 09/04/2019 LA03/2018/0539/A Antrim and Newtownabbey 15
Mr Martin Kane Dismissed 09/04/2019 LA06/2017/1273/O Ards and North Down 58
Mr Patrick McAuley EnforcementNoticeQuashed 09/04/2019 LA02/2017/0140/CA Mid and East Antrim 44
Mr David Percy Dismissed 08/04/2019 LA03/2018/0518/O Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr Darren Mallon Dismissed 04/04/2019 LA08/2018/1132/O Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
David Gordon Dismissed 03/04/2019 LA07/2018/0331/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Jim Maguire Withdrawn 02/04/2019 LA04/2017/2045/F Belfast 58
Raymond Hayes Dismissed 01/04/2019 LA10/2018/0784/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Sarah McIlhagger Dismissed 29/03/2019 LA01/2017/0959/O Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mrs Dawn Watson Dismissed 29/03/2019 LA06/2018/0256/O Ards and North Down 58
Glenview Green Energy Allowed 28/03/2019 LA02/2017/0715/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr Gordon Thompson Dismissed 27/03/2019 LA11/2015/0518/F Derry and Strabane 58
Ms Emma Hogg Allowed 26/03/2019 LA04/2018/0800/A Belfast 58
Assured Energy LLP Withdrawn 25/03/2019 LA01/2016/0373/CA & EN/2018/0018 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Mr George Canning Withdrawn 21/03/2019 EN/2018/0159 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Mrs C. McAleenan Dismissed 21/03/2019 LA03/2018/0228/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr Brendan Maginn Dismissed 21/03/2019 R/2014/0079/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Brendan Maginn EnforcementNoticeUpheld 21/03/2019 EN/2018/0091 Newry, Mourne and Down 44
Mr Martin Campbell EnforcementNoticeUpheld 21/03/2019 EN/2018/0142 Mid and East Antrim 143
Mr Andrew McNeill EnforcementNoticeUpheld 21/03/2019 LA02/2017/0169/CA Mid and East Antrim 44
Michael Blaney Withdrawn 20/03/2019 EN/2018/0234 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Mr Martin Campbell Dismissed 19/03/2019 LA02/2018/0079/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr MICHEAL BOYLE Dismissed 19/03/2019 LA01/2017/1347/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Antrim Tile & Bath Dismissed 15/03/2019 LA03/2018/0746/A Antrim and Newtownabbey 15
Joan Henderson Dismissed 13/03/2019 LA07/2018/0747/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr and Mrs McMurray Dismissed 13/03/2019 LA07/2017/0290/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Jim Kelly Dismissed 12/03/2019 LA01/2016/0046/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Clifford Parke Allowed 12/03/2019 LA07/2018/0865/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 11/03/2019 LA04/2018/0673/A Belfast 58
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 11/03/2019 LA04/2018/0858/F Belfast 58
Mr Michael Johnson Dismissed 11/03/2019 LA07/2018/0360/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
David McCullough Dismissed 11/03/2019 LA06/2018/0214/A Ards and North Down 15
Colin McClean Allowed 06/03/2019 LA01/2017/0822/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Matthew Rodden Dismissed 05/03/2019 LA03/2018/0218/LDE Antrim and Newtownabbey
Mr & Mrs G Cunningham Allowed 05/03/2019 LA07/2017/0691/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Adam Irvine Dismissed 04/03/2019 LA04/2018/9048/G DRD Roads Service
Mr Arthur Magill Dismissed 01/03/2019 ROC UT 5106 Northern Ireland Environment Agency
Mr Gary & Mrs Tracy Howell EnforcementNoticeQuashed 28/02/2019 X/2014/0065/CA Ards and North Down 143
Tracey & Gary Howell Allowed 28/02/2019 LA06/2017/1354/LDE Ards and North Down
South Ulster Housing Association Dismissed 28/02/2019 LA04/2017/1505/F Belfast 58
Mr Billy Quinn Dismissed 28/02/2019 LA03/2018/0654/LDE Antrim and Newtownabbey
Mr & Mrs H Coulter Dismissed 26/02/2019 LA07/2018/0220/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr & Mrs J Quinn Dismissed 25/02/2019 LA05/2018/0662/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Jim Robb Allowed 22/02/2019 LA11/2018/0182/LDE Derry and Strabane
Mr Ryan O'Kane Withdrawn 21/02/2019 LA10/2017/1337/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Joanne Allison Dismissed 20/02/2019 LA03/18/RO/28 DRD Roads Service
Brian & Laura Fealy Dismissed 20/02/2019 LA07/2017/0699/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Ronnie Wallace Allowed 19/02/2019 LA02/2018/0492/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Mrs Marie Boyd Allowed 18/02/2019 la05/2018/0604/o Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr Billy Quinn Allowed 13/02/2019 LA03/2017/0790/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 60
Mr Mark Harding Allowed 13/02/2019 LA06/2017/0904/F Ards and North Down 58
Mr Gordon Duff Dismissed 13/02/2019 LA06/2017/1406/F Ards and North Down 58
Mr & Mrs Cecilia Hannon Dismissed 12/02/2019 LA08/2017/1127/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mr Pete Boyle Allowed 12/02/2019 LA04/2017/2775/F Belfast 58
Mr Philip & Davey McCullough EnforcementNoticeQuashed 11/02/2019 EN/2017/0131 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Mr Philip & Davey McCullough EnforcementNoticeTermsVaried 11/02/2019 EN/2017/0130 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Fermac Properties Ltd Dismissed 11/02/2019 LA03/2018/0648/A Antrim and Newtownabbey 15
Mr Leonard Cardwell Allowed 07/02/2019 LA06/2018/0248/F Ards and North Down 58
Mr Seamus Quigg Dismissed 07/02/2019 LA01/2018/0405/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Ballynagilly Wind Energy Ltd Withdrawn 06/02/2019 LA09/2015/0459/F Mid Ulster 58
Mr Robert Maxwell Withdrawn 05/02/2019 NC2079/18 Northern Ireland Environment Agency
Mr David Gilmore EnforcementNoticeQuashed 01/02/2019 LA11/2017/0085/CA Derry and Strabane 44
Mr Uel Kane Dismissed 31/01/2019 LA01/2017/0857 Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Uel Kane Dismissed 31/01/2019 LA01/2017/0858/O Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Halls Pig Farm EnforcementNoticeQuashed 31/01/2019 EN/2018/0124 Antrim and Newtownabbey 44
Mr Graham Bell Dismissed 30/01/2019 I/2014/0399/F Mid Ulster 58
Car Park Services Ltd & Slaney Developments Allowed 28/01/2019 LA04/2017/1375 Belfast 58
Julian Crothers Dismissed 28/01/2019 LA05/2017/0597/O Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr Richard White Dismissed 28/01/2019 LA06/2015/0337/F Ards and North Down 58
Christopher Lynch Withdrawn 25/01/2019 EN/2018/0246 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Henry Group (NI) Limited EnforcementNoticeQuashed 21/01/2019 LA03/2016/0377/CA Antrim and Newtownabbey 44
Mr Patrick Gilloway EnforcementNoticeQuashed 21/01/2019 EN/2018/0201 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Mr Brendan Gibney Dismissed 21/01/2019 LA07/2017/1394/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Antrim Construction Company Ltd Dismissed 21/01/2019 LA06/2018/0107/A Ards and North Down 15
Mrs Rosie McDonagh Dismissed 17/01/2019 LA10/2018/0029/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Mr James Stewart Withdrawn 17/01/2019 EN/2018/0150 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Farrans Homes Allowed 16/01/2019 LA05/2016/1050/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Farrans Homes Allowed 16/01/2019 LA05/2016/0686/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr Hamilton EnforcementNoticeTermsVaried 14/01/2019 LA06/2015/0090/CA Ards and North Down 44
Rangol Properties Ltd Dismissed 11/01/2019 LA02/2017/1041/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr Craig Baxter Withdrawn 09/01/2019 LA07/2018/0554/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Robert & Mrs Ester McMitchell EnforcementNoticeUpheld 04/01/2019 LA03/2018/0230/CA Antrim and Newtownabbey 44
Tranquility Ireland Dismissed 04/01/2019 LA07/2017/1192/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr James and Kevin Donnelly Allowed 31/12/2018 LA07/2018/0467/LDE Newry, Mourne and Down
Ms Mary Slane Dismissed 21/12/2018 LA07/2018/0464/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Geoffrey Eakin Dismissed 21/12/2018 LA03/2018/0531/A Antrim and Newtownabbey 15
Mr Stephen Kirk Dismissed 20/12/2018 LA06/2017/1199/F Ards and North Down 58
Dermot McSorley Allowed 20/12/2018 LA11/2017/0242/F Derry and Strabane 58
Mr Stephen Kirk Dismissed 20/12/2018 LA06/2018/0178/A Ards and North Down 15
Robert McAlea Allowed 18/12/2018 LA04/2017/2206/F Belfast 58
Mr G Scullion Allowed 18/12/2018 LA02/2018/0188/O Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr Damien Heffron Dismissed 18/12/2018 LA03/2017/0458/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mrs Teresa Drayne Dismissed 17/12/2018 LA04/2018/0195/F Belfast 58
Mr Raymond Hall Allowed 12/12/2018 LA04/2018/0085/O Belfast 58
J&J McKibbin Withdrawn 12/12/2018 LA07/2017/0701/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Charlie Hillick Allowed 12/12/2018 LA04/2018/0542/F Belfast 58
Scott & Ewing Ltd Withdrawn 11/12/2018 LA10/2017/0081/CA Fermanagh and Omagh 44
Mr Martin McCoy Dismissed 11/12/2018 LA03/2018/0226/LDP Antrim and Newtownabbey
Mr Keith McFarland Dismissed 10/12/2018 LA10/2017/1040/O Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Mr Colin Rea Allowed 10/12/2018 LA02/2017/0902/O Mid and East Antrim 58
Dr Aiden & Roisin Malanaphy EnforcementNoticeUpheld 07/12/2018 LA10/2017/0076/CA Fermanagh and Omagh 44
Mr Hugh Millar Dismissed 07/12/2018 LA09/2017/0475/O Mid Ulster 58
Mr Paul Lennon Dismissed 06/12/2018 LA02/2018/0158/O Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr James Purdy Dismissed 05/12/2018 LA07/2018/0373/LDE Newry, Mourne and Down
Mr John Quinn EnforcementNoticeTermsVaried 04/12/2018 LA11/2015/0137/CA Derry and Strabane 44
Mrs Bridget Hasson Dismissed 03/12/2018 LA07/2017/1802/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Joseph Hughes Allowed 29/11/2018 LA09/2016/0103/CA Mid Ulster 143
Mr Cuan Boake Dismissed 28/11/2018 LA02/2016/0453/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr Seamus Quigg Dismissed 27/11/2018 LA01/2018/0406/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr George Armstrong Dismissed 26/11/2018 LA05/2016/1178/O Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr & Mrs Gerard Turner EnforcementNoticeQuashed 23/11/2018 EN/2018/0096 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Mr James Donnelly Withdrawn 23/11/2018 LA07/2017/0665/LDE Newry, Mourne and Down
Mr Sean Nugent Dismissed 23/11/2018 LA07/2018/0166/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Michael Doherty Dismissed 22/11/2018 LA01/2017/1013/O Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Charlie Dowdalls Dismissed 21/11/2018 LA10/2018/0010/O Fermanagh and Omagh 58