PAC - Planning Appeals Commission Appeal Decisions

Appeal Decisions

PAC Reference Appellant(s) Decision Decision Date Planning Service Reference Planning Office Article
Mr Niall Braniff Allowed 16/01/2020 LA07/2019/0013/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Kenny Guiney Dismissed 15/01/2020 LA08/2018/1272/O Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mr Harvey Lynch and Eddie Ferguson Dismissed 14/01/2020 LA07/2017/1799/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Gary Higgins Dismissed 14/01/2020 LA04/2019/0770/A Belfast 15
Marion Gray Allowed 14/01/2020 LA09/2019/0332/O Mid Ulster 78
WGK Homes Ltd Dismissed 13/01/2020 LA05/2018/1017/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr Michael Simpson Dismissed 10/01/2020 LA02/2019/0007/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Abo Wind NI Ltd Dismissed 08/01/2020 LA01/2017/1654/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Roy McCrea EnforcementNoticeUpheld 08/01/2020 LA11/2016/0041/CA Derry and Strabane 44
Mr Sam McCalden Withdrawn 07/01/2020 LA04/2019/0142/F Belfast 58
Mr Sam McCalden Withdrawn 07/01/2020 EN/2019/0196 Belfast 44
Hill Power Ltd Allowed 06/01/2020 LA08/2018/1648/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 60
Mr Raymond Mervyn Dallas Withdrawn 06/01/2020 EN/2019/0125 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Bentley Leisure Allowed 03/01/2020 LA11/2017/0764/F Derry and Strabane 58
Bentley Leisure Allowed 03/01/2020 LA11/2017/0763/LBC Derry and Strabane 96
Mr N Dodds Allowed 30/12/2019 LA07/2018/1995/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Norman Roddy Dismissed 24/12/2019 LA04/2019/0661/A Belfast 15
J McAteer Allowed 23/12/2019 LA07/2018/1946/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Roy McCrea EnforcementNoticeTermsVaried 23/12/2019 LA11/2016/0168/CA Derry and Strabane 44
Cloughorr Investments Ltd Withdrawn 20/12/2019 LA01/2019/0078/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Conor Ward Dismissed 20/12/2019 LA04/2018/2643/F Belfast 58
Thompson Fuels Holding Co Allowed 20/12/2019 LA08/2019/0016/LDP Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon
Mr Mark Ellesmere EnforcementNoticeQuashed 20/12/2019 IRF 64/19 Northern Ireland Environment Agency
Mr Gareth Culbertson Withdrawn 19/12/2019 LA05/2018/1094/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr Graham Hancock Allowed 18/12/2019 LA07/2018/1451/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Cavan Johnston Dismissed 17/12/2019 LA07/2019/0018/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
The Auction Yard Ltd EnforcementNoticeTermsVaried 16/12/2019 LA03/2017/0391/CA Antrim and Newtownabbey 44
Mr Tom Shields Allowed 16/12/2019 LA07/2018/1772/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Morgan Crone Allowed 16/12/2019 LA05/2017/1189/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Developments Ltd Blackgate Dismissed 16/12/2019 LA07/2017/1488/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Alan Wilton InterimFinding 12/12/2019 LA05/2016/1140/F Lisburn and Castlereagh
N Crean Dismissed 11/12/2019 LA07/2019/0164/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Suzanne Murray Withdrawn 09/12/2019 LA08/2019/0683/O Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mr M Hillis Dismissed 09/12/2019 LA07/2018/1343/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Brendan McQuillan Dismissed 05/12/2019 LA03/2018/0855/O Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr Christopher Rea Dismissed 02/12/2019 LA07/2018/1371/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Paul Scott Allowed 28/11/2019 LA07/2018/0128/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Noel Graham Dismissed 28/11/2019 LA07/2017/1849/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Kells BES Ltd Allowed 27/11/2019 LA03/2018/0984/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mrs Frances Menary EnforcementNoticeUpheld 26/11/2019 EN/2019/0135 Causeway Coast and Glens
Suzanne Heaney Dismissed 26/11/2019 LA04/2019/9018/G DRD Roads Service
Mr Martin Heatley Dismissed 25/11/2019 LA04/2018/2514/A Belfast 15
Mr Sean O'Hare Allowed 25/11/2019 LA07/2018/1266/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Maurice Girvin Dismissed 22/11/2019 LA04/2018/1483/O Belfast 58
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 22/11/2019 LA04/2018/2745/A Belfast
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 22/11/2019 LA04/2018/2744/F Belfast 58
Mr David Cooke Dismissed 22/11/2019 LA05/2017/1297/O Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Cyril Hamilton Allowed 21/11/2019 LA07/2018/1663/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr John Annett Allowed 19/11/2019 LA07/2017/0707/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Michael Fairfowl Dismissed 18/11/2019 LA04/2018/2529/A Belfast 15
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 18/11/2019 LA04/2018/2151/A Belfast 58
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 18/11/2019 LA04/2018/2164/F Belfast 58
Mr Declan Colgan EnforcementNoticeQuashed 18/11/2019 LA10/2018/0129/CA Fermanagh and Omagh 44
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 18/11/2019 LA04/2018/2732/F Belfast 58
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 18/11/2019 LA04/2018/2736/A Belfast 15
Mr Fergus Kelly Dismissed 13/11/2019 LA01/2017/1449/O Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Gareth Haughey Dismissed 13/11/2019 LA05/2016/0973/A Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Brenda Rooney Dismissed 11/11/2019 LA07/2019/0488/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr William McDonnell Allowed 11/11/2019 LA07/2018/1792/LDE Newry, Mourne and Down
Mr Yiu Hei Shek EnforcementNoticeQuashed 11/11/2019 LA04/2018/0343/CA Belfast 44
NI The Jungle Allowed 08/11/2019 LA09/2018/1597/LDE Mid Ulster
Copart UK Ltd Allowed 05/11/2019 LA07/2018/1381/LDE Newry, Mourne and Down
Greenbay Apartments Ltd Dismissed 01/11/2019 LA02/2017/0722/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr Paul Allen Allowed 31/10/2019 LA04/2018/0386/F Belfast 58
Mrs Sue Avery Dismissed 31/10/2019 LA03/2018/0422/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Michael Doran Allowed 31/10/2019 LA07/2018/0185/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Barrie Elkin Dismissed 31/10/2019 LA04/2018/2301/F Belfast 58
Beatty Fuels EnforcementNoticeUpheld 29/10/2019 LA03/2018/0441/CA Antrim and Newtownabbey 44
Mr Joseph Thompson Allowed 28/10/2019 LA08/2018/1269/LDP Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon
Mr Kieran Campbell Allowed 28/10/2019 LA07/2019/0277/LDE Newry, Mourne and Down
Ellen Brennan Dismissed 28/10/2019 LA07/2018/1417/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Brian Somers Dismissed 28/10/2019 LA03/2019/0098/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Ms A Dunford Allowed 22/10/2019 LA07/2018/1273/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr James Ferguson Dismissed 21/10/2019 LA04/2018/1261/F Belfast 58
Mr Gary Madgwick Dismissed 21/10/2019 LA07/2018/1677/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Roy Walker Granted 21/10/2019 LA04/2018/2233/A Belfast 15
Gary Madgwick Dismissed 21/10/2019 LA07/2018/1677/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Chris King EnforcementNoticeUpheld 15/10/2019 EN/2019/0034 Lisburn and Castlereagh 44
Halftown Ltd Withdrawn 15/10/2019 LA06/2016/0023/CA Ards and North Down
Mr Marc Morgan Dismissed 10/10/2019 LA07/2018/0672/RM Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Christopher Brown Allowed 09/10/2019 LA07/2018/1412/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Michael Molloy Dismissed 08/10/2019 LA08/2018/0741/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mr E Rea Allowed 07/10/2019 LA07/2018/0340/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr John Keenan Dismissed 07/10/2019 LA04/2018/1234/LBC Belfast 96
Mr James Morgan Allowed 07/10/2019 LA07/2018/1635/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
PT Bowring Dismissed 07/10/2019 LA08/2017/1484/O Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mr John Keenan Dismissed 07/10/2019 LA04/2018/0708/F Belfast 58
Rev John Withy EnforcementNoticeUpheld 07/10/2019 LA11/2016/0008/CA Derry and Strabane 44
Ms Teresa Drayne Dismissed 03/10/2019 LA04/2018/2198/F Belfast 58
Telephonica UK Ltd Allowed 02/10/2019 LA04/2018/2410/F Belfast 58
Mr Damien McAllister Dismissed 30/09/2019 LA01/2018/1111/O Causeway Coast and Glens 58
TAKE IT EASY HOMES Allowed 30/09/2019 LA10/2018/1488/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
TAKE IT EASY HOMES Allowed 30/09/2019 LA10/2018/1487/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Maria Morgan Allowed 30/09/2019 LA07/2018/0787/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Pat & John O'Donnell Dismissed 27/09/2019 LA10/2018/1300/O Fermanagh and Omagh
Mr Chris Kennedy Dismissed 27/09/2019 LA07/2019/0210/LDE Newry, Mourne and Down
Mrs Josephine Watson Dismissed 26/09/2019 LA07/2018/0190/RM Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Brian Mulholland Withdrawn 25/09/2019 P/2014/0920 Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr & Mrs Graham Dismissed 23/09/2019 LA08/2018/1528/O Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Karen Turley Dismissed 20/09/2019 LA07/2018/1043/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Miss Leah Patterson Dismissed 19/09/2019 LA07/2018/0963/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mrs Rebekah Wilson Allowed 18/09/2019 LA07/2018/1756/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Liam Kelly InterimFinding 17/09/2019 EN/2018/0198 Department of the Environment 44
PBD Contracts Ltd Allowed 17/09/2019 LA05/2017/1030/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr Jim Hanna Dismissed 16/09/2019 LA03/2017/1066/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr William Lindsay Dismissed 16/09/2019 LA07/2018/0085/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Norman Roddy Allowed 12/09/2019 LA04/2019/0225/A Belfast 15
Mr Darren Wylie Dismissed 12/09/2019 LA02/2018/1097/LDE Mid and East Antrim
Cloughorr Investments Allowed 11/09/2019 LA01/2018/1114/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr B McClelland Dismissed 06/09/2019 LA08/2017/0655/O Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mr Adrian Daly Withdrawn 06/09/2019 LA09/2018/0102/CA Mid Ulster 44
Ms Naiomh Morgan Dismissed 03/09/2019 LA07/2017/1252/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Declan Clarke Allowed 03/09/2019 LA07/2018/0270/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Sean McNicholl Allowed 03/09/2019 LA01/2018/1130/O Causeway Coast and Glens
Mr Ian & Gladys Heatherington EnforcementNoticeQuashed 02/09/2019 LA10/2018/0235/CA Fermanagh and Omagh 44
Mr Neil Watson Dismissed 30/08/2019 LA05/2018/0490/O Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr Eugene Mullan Dismissed 30/08/2019 LA01/2017/1580/O Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Paul McAlinden Withdrawn 30/08/2019 P/2014/0107/F Newry, Mourne and Down
Mr John Farrell Dismissed 28/08/2019 LA08/2018/0516/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mr Michael Mackin Dismissed 27/08/2019 LA08/2018/0196/O Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mr Eric McVea Dismissed 23/08/2019 LA06/2017/0491/F Ards and North Down
North Lisburn Development Consortium Ltd Dismissed 23/08/2019 S/2011/0049/O Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mrs Jennifer S Currie Allowed 23/08/2019 LA02/2018/0734/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Moorefield Investments Ltd Dismissed 20/08/2019 LA03/2019/0102/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr Francis Toal Dismissed 20/08/2019 LA08/2018/1051/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon
Mrs Marcia Lister Withdrawn 19/08/2019 LA04/2019/0145/LDP Belfast
Mr Gordon Semple Dismissed 14/08/2019 LA06/2017/1224/F Ards and North Down 58
Mr Michael Daly Dismissed 14/08/2019 LA10/2018/0251/O Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Mr Jim McCabe Dismissed 14/08/2019 LA07/2017/1485/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Michael McColgan EnforcementNoticeQuashed 14/08/2019 A/2014/0026/CA Derry and Strabane 44
Renewable Energy Systems Ltd Allowed 12/08/2019 A/2014/0112/F Derry and Strabane 33
Renewable Energy Systems Ltd Allowed 12/08/2019 A/2014/0114/F Derry and Strabane 32
Mr Joseph Walls Allowed 11/08/2019 LA07/2018/0403/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Rev John Farr Dismissed 08/08/2019 LA05/2017/1277/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Renewable Energy Systems Ltd Allowed 08/08/2019 A/2012/0401/F Derry and Strabane 32
G Knox Dismissed 07/08/2019 LA04/2017/2247/O Belfast 58
Mrs Noelle Macauley Dismissed 05/08/2019 LA04/2018/2282/0 Belfast 58
Mr Andrew McMullan Allowed 05/08/2019 LA01/2018/0842/O Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Colm McGarvey Allowed 02/08/2019 LA10/2018/0798/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
EML Lesley House EML Lesley House NotValid 31/07/2019 LA04/2019/0033/CA Belfast
Mr Trevor Crawford Allowed 31/07/2019 LA10/2018/0746/O Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Anne Marie Hughes Allowed 30/07/2019 LA09/2018/9334 DRD Roads Service
Kieran Shields Withdrawn 30/07/2019 LA07/2016/0305/CA Newry, Mourne and Down 44
Mrs Bridie McElroy Dismissed 29/07/2019 LA10/2018/0660/O Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Fergal O'Neill EnforcementNoticeUpheld 29/07/2019 LA09/2017/0058/CA Mid Ulster 44
Mr Ryan Rogan Allowed 26/07/2019 LA07/2018/0532/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mrs Julie Coyle EnforcementNoticeQuashed 23/07/2019 A/2013/0125/CA Derry and Strabane 44
Mr Alan Hunter Dismissed 23/07/2019 LA01/2018/1303/LDE Causeway Coast and Glens
Mr Anthony McIlwrath Dismissed 22/07/2019 LA07/2018/0862/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58