PAC - Planning Appeals Commission Appeal Decisions

Appeal Decisions

PAC Reference Appellant(s) Decision Decision Date Planning Service Reference Planning Office Article
Michael & Marion Young Dismissed 18/07/2018 LA07/2017/1388/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Alan Murphy Dismissed 18/07/2018 LA04/2016/2440/a Belfast 15
Mr Steven Campbell Dismissed 18/07/2018 LA07/2017/0687/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Marie Morgan Dismissed 17/07/2018 LA10/2017/0866/O Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Mrs B, Miss J & Mr J Robertson Dismissed 16/07/2018 LA06/2017/0309/O Ards and North Down 58
Taggart Homes EnforcementNoticeQuashed 11/07/2018 LA11/2016/0143/CA Derry and Strabane 143
Mr RG & Mrs G McCullagh EnforcementNoticeUpheld 11/07/2018 EN/2017/0236 Mid and East Antrim 44
Taggart Homes Allowed 11/07/2018 LA11/2016/0869/F Derry and Strabane 58
Taggart Homes EnforcementNoticeQuashed 11/07/2018 LA11/2016/0143/CA Derry and Strabane 143
Mr Gerard Donnelly Dismissed 06/07/2018 LA07/2017/1627/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Attwood Allowed 06/07/2018 LA11/2016/0326/F Derry and Strabane
David Hickey Dismissed 06/07/2018 LA11/2016/1066/F Derry and Strabane 58
Mr Martin Heatley Dismissed 05/07/2018 LA04/2017/0969/A Belfast 15
Mr Diarmuid Lavery Allowed 04/07/2018 LA08/2017/0739/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mrs Lynn Acheson Dismissed 04/07/2018 LA08/2016/1428/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
DBM Contracts Dismissed 04/07/2018 LA07/2016/1647/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Kenneth Anderson Dismissed 03/07/2018 LA08/2016/1132/O Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mr Colum Mackle Withdrawn 02/07/2018 WML30/22 Northern Ireland Environment Agency
Mr Eamonn and Edward Clancy EnforcementNoticeUpheld 02/07/2018 LA10/2016/0099/CA Fermanagh and Omagh 44
Mr William Jordan Allowed 02/07/2018 LA07/2017/1095/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Bon marche Dismissed 29/06/2018 LA05/2016/0049/A Lisburn and Castlereagh 15
Nuport LR LTD Allowed 29/06/2018 LA02/2017/0878/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr David Vance Dismissed 28/06/2018 LA10/2016/0422/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
HWR Kohner Dismissed 28/06/2018 LA04/2017/1698/F Belfast 58
Mr Kieran McManus Dismissed 28/06/2018 LA10/2017/1157/O Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Ms Joan and Mr Conor Colgan Withdrawn 27/06/2018 LA05/2017/0698/O Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr Roy Walker Dismissed 26/06/2018 LA04/2017/0692/A Belfast
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 25/06/2018 LA04/2017/1828/A Belfast 15
Mr Conor Coyle EnforcementNoticeQuashed 25/06/2018 A/2012/0031/CA EN/2017/0161 Derry and Strabane
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 25/06/2018 LA04/2017/1844/F Belfast 58
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 25/06/2018 LA04/2017/1873/F Belfast 58
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 25/06/2018 LA04/2017/1877/A Belfast 15
Mr Conor Coyle EnforcementNoticeQuashed 25/06/2018 EN/2017/0262 Derry and Strabane
Mr John Farren Allowed 22/06/2018 LA01/2017/0336/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Brian Hollywood Dismissed 21/06/2018 LA07/2017/0856/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Paul Drennan Dismissed 21/06/2018 LA03/18/RO/01 DRD Roads Service
William Anderson Granted 20/06/2018 LA10/2016/0941/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Joanne Morrison Dismissed 20/06/2018 LA08/2016/0041/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
William Anderson EnforcementNoticeUpheld 20/06/2018 LA10/2016/0104/CA Fermanagh and Omagh
Mr Hugh Johnston Dismissed 18/06/2018 LA10/2017/0823/LBC Fermanagh and Omagh
Dunmore 2 Wind Farm Ltd Allowed 15/06/2018 B/2013/0241/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 14/06/2018 LA04/2017/1865/A Belfast 15
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 14/06/2018 LA04/2017/1848/F Belfast 58
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 14/06/2018 LA04/2017/1825/A Belfast 15
Mr Tom Fisher Allowed 14/06/2018 LA04/2017/1858/F Belfast 58
Mr Red Flyer NI LTD Allowed 11/06/2018 LA02/2016/0408/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Dr Christopher McGimpsey Dismissed 08/06/2018 LA06/2016/0228/F Ards and North Down 58
Rozana Huq Dismissed 06/06/2018 LA07/2017/0018/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mark Adamson Allowed 06/06/2018 LA06/2017/0179/O Ards and North Down 58
Mrs Sue Avery Withdrawn 04/06/2018 LA03/2017/0143/CA Antrim and Newtownabbey
Sarah Peilow Withdrawn 04/06/2018 LA08/2016/1332/TPO Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon
SCS Allowed 04/06/2018 LA07/2017/0172/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr William Campbell InterimFinding 31/05/2018 LA03/2016/0831/O Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr Cecil Shaw Dismissed 31/05/2018 LA05/2017/0200/F Lisburn and Castlereagh
Mr Noel McKee Withdrawn 31/05/2018 LA03/2017/0608/O Antrim and Newtownabbey 15
Mr Eamonn Grimley Allowed 30/05/2018 LA04/2017/1658/A Belfast 58
Mr John McLaughlin Allowed 29/05/2018 LA01/2017/0697/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Thomas Quinn Dismissed 29/05/2018 ASSI 030-009138 Northern Ireland Environment Agency
Mr John Morgan Dismissed 24/05/2018 LA07/2017/0563/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Michael McGonagle InterimFinding 24/05/2018 A/2012/0020/CA Derry and Strabane 44
Elgin Energy Allowed 24/05/2018 LA03/2016/0135/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr Ian McCulla Allowed 24/05/2018 LA06/2017/0898/A Ards and North Down 15
Mr Michael McGonagle InterimFinding 24/05/2018 EN/2016/0199 Derry and Strabane 44
I Lappin Allowed 24/05/2018 LA05/2015/0588/O Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr Bernard Morgan Dismissed 23/05/2018 LA07/2017/1138/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
B & P Cunningham EnforcementNoticeUpheld 22/05/2018 LA07/2016/0207/CA Newry, Mourne and Down 44
Mr Liam McKay NotValid 21/05/2018 LA01/2016/0574/F Causeway Coast and Glens
Nu Scren Ltd Allowed 21/05/2018 LA07/2017/1400/LDE Newry, Mourne and Down
Mr Joe McGarrity Dismissed 21/05/2018 LA10/2017/0454/O Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Mr Joseph McLaughlin Dismissed 21/05/2018 LA02/2017/0302/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr John McIlhone Dismissed 18/05/2018 LA04/2017/0623/F Belfast 58
Mr Pedar McParland Dismissed 18/05/2018 LA08/2016/1253/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon
Mr John McIlhone Dismissed 18/05/2018 LA041/2017/0628/DCA Belfast 105(6)
Mr Declan Morris Dismissed 17/05/2018 LA10/2017/0878/O Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Mr C S Pearson Withdrawn 17/05/2018 LA06/2016/0207/F Ards and North Down 58
Mr Alan Hyde Dismissed 16/05/2018 LA03/2017/0005/LDE Antrim and Newtownabbey
Mr Norman Roddy Dismissed 15/05/2018 LA04/2017/1747/A Belfast 15
Mr Paul McAliskey EnforcementNoticeUpheld 15/05/2018 LA09/2017/0002/CA Mid Ulster 44
Mr Richard Beattie Dismissed 14/05/2018 LA10/2017/0278/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Mr Ciaran Owens EnforcementNoticeUpheld 14/05/2018 LA09/2016/0219/CA Mid Ulster 44
Mr Kieran King Allowed 10/05/2018 LA07/2017/0371/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Leonard Wilson Dismissed 10/05/2018 LA03/2017/0431/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Quayside Properties Ltd Dismissed 09/05/2018 LA07/2015/1123/LBC Newry, Mourne and Down 96
Mr Damian McMullan Allowed 09/05/2018 LA01/2016/1445/O Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr Fred Ferris Dismissed 08/05/2018 LA05/2016/1231/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Pauline Patricia Acton EnforcementNoticeUpheld 08/05/2018 LA02/2016/0068/CA Mid and East Antrim 44
Mr Joseph O'Hare EnforcementNoticeTermsVaried 08/05/2018 P/2013/0150/CA Newry, Mourne and Down
Organic Fertilisers Limted Allowed 04/05/2018 WML 38/07 Northern Ireland Environment Agency
Organic Fertilisers Limted EnforcementNoticeQuashed 04/05/2018 EN/2016/0030 Newry, Mourne and Down 44
Mr Uel Weir Dismissed 03/05/2018 LA08/2017/0850/TPO Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon
Madden and Finucane Solicitors Allowed 02/05/2018 LA04/2017/0642/A Belfast 15
Mr Rodney Young Dismissed 01/05/2018 Y/2013/0245/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Derry Amusements and Gaming Ltd Allowed 24/04/2018 LA11/2016/0964/F Derry and Strabane 58
Arabic Investments Allowed 24/04/2018 LA04/2016/0487/F Belfast 58
Ms E A Beatty Dismissed 23/04/2018 LA05/2015/0721/O Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr Martin Heatley Allowed 23/04/2018 LA04/2017/0483/A Belfast 15
Mr Edward McAloon Dismissed 23/04/2018 LA10/2017/0517/LDE Fermanagh and Omagh
Mr JOHN DAVISON EnforcementNoticeQuashed 23/04/2018 LA06/2016/0276/CA Lisburn and Castlereagh 44
Mr Brendan Smith EnforcementNoticeUpheld 23/04/2018 P/2014/0095/CA Newry, Mourne and Down 44
Mr Fergal Rafferty Dismissed 20/04/2018 LA07/2017/0370/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Graham Bell Allowed 18/04/2018 LA09/2017/0272/F Mid Ulster 58
Mr David Mahon EnforcementNoticeUpheld 16/04/2018 LA10/2017/0065/CA Fermanagh and Omagh
Mr David Mahon EnforcementNoticeUpheld 16/04/2018 LA10/2017/0064/CA Fermanagh and Omagh
Mr Jonathan Parkhill NotValid 16/04/2018 B/2012/0054/CA & EN/2017/0081 Causeway Coast and Glens 44
Mr Brendan McCartan Dismissed 13/04/2018 LA07/2017/1174/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Claire Sizer Withdrawn 13/04/2018 DCW/23/2017/G DRD Roads Service
Mr Liam Hegarty Dismissed 11/04/2018 LA03/2017/0068/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr Liam McGrath Dismissed 09/04/2018 LA04/2016/1486/F Belfast 58
Mr Caolan Quinn Dismissed 30/03/2018 LA07/2016/0477/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr S McClelland Dismissed 30/03/2018 LA11/2016/0710/O Derry and Strabane 58
Mr Neil Hutton Dismissed 30/03/2018 LA04/2016/2247/F Belfast 58
Ms Mary Rooney Dismissed 30/03/2018 LA07/2017/0624/F Newry, Mourne and Down 60
SBA SBA Dismissed 30/03/2018 LA11/2016/0988/F Derry and Strabane 58
Mr Jason McKelvey Dismissed 29/03/2018 K/2015/0119/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
Mr Gerard Connolly Dismissed 29/03/2018 A/2013/0498/F Derry and Strabane 58
Mr Cathal Sloan Dismissed 28/03/2018 LA07/2017/0145/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr John Kelly Allowed 26/03/2018 LA04/2017/0392/A Belfast 58
Mr Philip Newell Dismissed 26/03/2018 LA05/2017/0135/O Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr Matt Burns Dismissed 22/03/2018 LA07/2016/0381/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Cuan Boake NotValid 20/03/2018 LA02/2016/0453/F Mid and East Antrim 58
Brian Fairley Dismissed 16/03/2018 LA05/2017/0334/F Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Mr John Whiteford Withdrawn 15/03/2018 LA03/2017/0620/LDE Antrim and Newtownabbey
Mr William McCluskey Dismissed 14/03/2018 LA07/2016/0365/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Darren O'Hagan Dismissed 14/03/2018 LA07/2016/0802/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
G R Homes Dismissed 14/03/2018 A/2010/0489/F Derry and Strabane 58
Mr Declan Kearney Dismissed 13/03/2018 LA07/2017/0375/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Seamus and Philomena Lappin EnforcementNoticeTermsVaried 13/03/2018 LA08/2016/0187/CA Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 44
DJ Holmes Developments Dismissed 13/03/2018 LA02/2016/0188/F Mid and East Antrim 58
D + M Downey Withdrawn 12/03/2018 LA01/2016/0952/F Newry, Mourne and Down
Sharon Toner Allowed 07/03/2018 LA08/2017/0468/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Acorn Developments Dismissed 07/03/2018 LA08/2016/0278/F Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon 58
Mr Graham Bell Dismissed 05/03/2018 I/2014/0399/F Mid Ulster 58
Timothy Clarke Dismissed 05/03/2018 LA02/2017/0536/O Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr Francie McNicholl Dismissed 01/03/2018 LA01/2017/0380/A Causeway Coast and Glens 15
Mr Gary O'Hare Dismissed 28/02/2018 LA07/2017/0077/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Herbal Restaurants Ltd. Dismissed 28/02/2018 LA04/2017/1214/A Belfast 15
MAM Development Ltd Dismissed 28/02/2018 A/2008/0125/F Derry and Strabane 58
Quarry Hill Wind Ltd Allowed 26/02/2018 LA03/2017/0328/F Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr & Mrs N McRoberts Allowed 23/02/2018 LA04/2017/1351/F Belfast 58
Mr Stuart Fulton Dismissed 23/02/2018 J/2015/0059/F Derry and Strabane 58
P & T Miskelly Dismissed 22/02/2018 LA07/2016/1537/O Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Wayne Windrum Dismissed 22/02/2018 LA04/2017/0105/O Belfast 58
Mr H Millar NotValid 22/02/2018 LA09/2017/0475/0 Mid Ulster 58
Mr Kenneth Veitch EnforcementNoticeQuashed 22/02/2018 L/2014/0067/CA Fermanagh and Omagh 44
Mark Rice Dismissed 21/02/2018 LA07/2015/0946/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Ms Joan Henderson Allowed 21/02/2018 LA07/2017/0053/LDE Newry, Mourne and Down
Blackgate Property Developments Limited Withdrawn 21/02/2018 LA07/2017/1039/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Jim Logan Dismissed 20/02/2018 LA04/2017/0573/F Belfast 58
Mr Francis O'Loughlin Allowed 20/02/2018 LA11/2016/0129/O Derry and Strabane 58
Mr Norman Roddy Allowed 19/02/2018 LA07/2017/1078/A Newry, Mourne and Down 15
Mr Norman Roddy Dismissed 16/02/2018 LA02/2017/0686/A Mid and East Antrim 15
Mr Roy Beattie Dismissed 15/02/2018 LA03/2016/1056/O Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr Alan Montgomery Allowed 15/02/2018 LA07/2016/1219/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Paul Smith Dismissed 15/02/2018 LA07/2015/0545/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr William Eric & Mrs Alana Rosborough EnforcementNoticeUpheld 13/02/2018 X/13/0090/CA Ards and North Down 44
Mr Canice Mallagan Dismissed 13/02/2018 LA03/2017/0487/O Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr Canice Mallagan Dismissed 13/02/2018 LA03/2017/0484/O Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr Desmond Dick Dismissed 12/02/2018 LA02/2016/0993/O Mid and East Antrim 58
Mr Michael Dougan Dismissed 12/02/2018 LA03/2017/0524/O Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr & Mrs E Kerr Dismissed 09/02/2018 LA07/2015/1381/F Newry, Mourne and Down 58
Mr Simon Hamill EnforcementNoticeUpheld 06/02/2018 LA03/2017/0145/CA Antrim and Newtownabbey
Mrs Jenny McBriar Dismissed 05/02/2018 LA06/2017/0286/O Ards and North Down 58
Mr Conal Treacy Dismissed 01/02/2018 ASSI 065-009063 Department of the Environment
Mr Brian McAvoy Allowed 31/01/2018 LA04/2017/1018/F Belfast 58
Mr Daniel Glover Dismissed 31/01/2018 LA05/2017/0196/O Lisburn and Castlereagh 58
Ms Katherine Hunter Allowed 30/01/2018 LA01/2016/1266/F Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr R.J Thompson Allowed 30/01/2018 LA03/2017/0224/O Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mrs Rosie McDonagh EnforcementNoticeTermsVaried 30/01/2018 EN/2017/0095 Fermanagh and Omagh 44
Mr William Carson Dismissed 29/01/2018 LA03/2017/0233/O Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Mr SAM JOHNSTON Dismissed 29/01/2018 LA03/2017/0554/O Antrim and Newtownabbey 58
Nicola Millar Dismissed 29/01/2018 LA01/2017/0004/O Causeway Coast and Glens 58
Mr David Pollock EnforcementNoticeUpheld 25/01/2018 LA10/2016/0003/CA Fermanagh and Omagh 44
Mr David Pollock Dismissed 25/01/2018 LA10/2016/1082/F Fermanagh and Omagh 58
MOF III Allowed 24/01/2018 not applicable Derry and Strabane
Premier Car Park Management Ltd Withdrawn 23/01/2018 LA04/2017/1441/F Belfast 58